The panel debate the reasons behind why there have been no musicians nominated for the title of The Greatest Scot.
The panel debate the reasons behind why there have been no musicians nominated for the title of The Greatest Scot.
04 November 2009 16:36 GMT
The panel debate the reasons behind why there have been no musicians nominated for the title of The Greatest Scot.
1. 09 Nov 2009 09:44Billy Bones said
In the header "how the panel decided" there's a video titled The panel debate the reasons behind why there have been no musicians nominated for the title of The Greatest Scot, The Greatest Scot panel discuss the lack of musical nominees!
What about Alex Harvey, The Sensational Alex Harvey!
2. 09 Nov 2009 21:45Skarecrow said
Alex Harvey was one of the peoples choice nominees not picked by the panel.
3. 10 Nov 2009 23:27biggercam said
I cannot believe Sir Walter Scott is not included in the shortlist. We would have no national identity without the Waverley Novels.
That said, it must be Burns
4. 26 Nov 2009 21:01leggylady said
I cannot believe that despite Midge Ure being on the list he wasn't put forward. As much as I am a fan of Annie Lennox, I'm sure that she herself would admit that Midge is a much more worthy candidate! They make mention of her achieving beyond the field of music, well the same could be said of Midge:
Ivor Novello and Grammy winner
Co-writer and producer of the World's ever biggest selling single (Do they Know it's Christmas?)raising £8M saving countless lives
Trustee of the Band Aid Trust
Musical director for the Princes Trust
Co-organiser of Live 8 at Murrayfield for the G8 summit
Patron for the Burnsong project
Founder of Tunited
He was awarded an OBE for his services to Music and Charity (20 years after Bob Geldof received his knighthood)
The list goes on and that's even before you mention his success as a songwriter and world record for having the most number ones under different band names (Slik, Visage, Band Aid, Midge Ure etc etc) and that's before you even mention co-writing the TOTP theme tune!!!!
I really think that the "panel" should have had a wee look on Wikipedia or better still the biography section of midgeure.com before dismissing him. I think they've made a terrible mistake. As for Annie Lennox being put through because you still see her late at night on BBC3... what the hell? Ultravox reformed this year and sold out EVERY gig of the tour! Midge has been on the tv countless times this year, not only in his capacity as lead singer of Ultravox (they also played the Isle of Wight festival which was televised) but also because he just recently returned to Africa for Save the Children..... for goodness sake people, do your research!!!!
I would hope, no EXPECT that he is on the list next year, as his ommission is a disgrace!!!
Posts are not actively monitored by STV. The views expressed are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of STV.
Wednesday, May 16th, 8:00pm
Cornwall with Caroline Quentin
Wednesday, May 16th, 7:30pm
Wednesday, May 16th, 7:00pm